Neighborhood · Northeast Florida
Stillwater homes for saleSt. Johns, FL
Stillwater, in St. Johns, FL, has 24 active listings for sale right now. 6 sales closed in the last 90 days at a median price of $382,500. Sold homes reached an accepted contract after a median of 61 days on the market.
Located inSt. JohnsSt. Johns County
ZIP code32259
Full MLS home browsing requires a free account and terms acceptance.
About Stillwater
Stillwater is a neighborhood in St. Johns, in St. Johns County. Nearby neighborhoods include South Hampton, Middlebourne, Durbin Crossing, and St Johns Forest. Single-family homes account for about 93% of recent listings, with townhouses making up the rest. Most homes were built from 2022 to 2026, and nearly all recent listings report a homeowners association.
The middle half of recently listed homes range from about 1,660 to 2,030 square feet, with a median size of about 1,890 square feet. Homes typically have two to three bedrooms. Over the past 12 months, the middle half of recent sale prices ranged from about $334,000 to $458,000, with a median sale price of about $374,000.
Written from MLS listing and sales records for this area. Figures are approximate.
Around Stillwater
Photos of nearby places from Google Maps, near the area's approximate center. They are not photos of homes for sale.
Where to buy
Schools, parks and amenities near Stillwater
Places close to Stillwater, with distances measured from the neighborhood's approximate center.
Local schools
Parks & outdoors
Everyday amenities
Places from Google Maps. School assignments depend on each home's address and can change, so confirm them with the school district before you buy. JaxHomes does not rate schools or neighborhoods.
Arrows compare finished months only: the last 3 full months with the 3 full months before. Total counts each property once, even if it was relisted, sold or unsold; still available is what remains at each interval’s end. Dotted segments mark incomplete intervals.
Stillwater · Weekly sale prices
Explore the marketListings ending without a sale
Expired/Unsold
9
57.1% up
Unsold exit rate
60.0%
7.3 pp up
Share of weekly exits without a sale
Exit rate = expired/unsold homes ÷ (sold + expired/unsold homes). Figures cover the selected period; arrows compare the last 3 finished months with the preceding 3. Changes in rates are percentage points (pp). Each home counts once, even if it was relisted. This is not a measure of failed demand.
Closed sales: Aug 15, 2026–Nov 12, 2026 · 6 sales. Total available includes sold and expired/unsold homes, not a peak simultaneous count. Each home counts once, even if it was relisted. Each interval uses its own sales sample; no sales means a gap. Small samples can be volatile.
Your next home is out there
Homes for sale in Stillwater
Explore homes on the market. Then find the ones that fit your life, your style, and what you love.
Create a free account and accept the MLS terms to see full home details. Availability can change.
JaxHomes.com is a buyer-focused service provided by ForSaleByPl.us, a fully licensed real estate brokerage in the state of Florida and member of the Northeast Florida MLS. Listing information is provided through a broker-sponsored Virtual Office Website for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be redistributed. A free account and terms acceptance are required to view listing details.
Listing data on this site is provided by realMLS (Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service) (Duval, St. Johns, Clay, Nassau). Listings from other multiple listing services are not shown.
Which home feels like you?
Let your preferences guide the search, not just a price range.
Map of Stillwater
● Area groups · Active listing counts at approximate area centers, not property locations or boundaries.
Streets with the most sales in Stillwater
Streets with at least 5 home sales in the last 12 months whose MLS records list Stillwater. Counts cover each whole street within its ZIP code, which can reach past Stillwater.
Neighborhoods near Stillwater
ZIP codes near Stillwater
Nearby means closest by approximate area center, not shared boundaries.
Explore every Northeast Florida neighborhoodJaxHomes.com is a buyer-focused service provided by ForSaleByPl.us, a fully licensed real estate brokerage in the state of Florida and member of the Northeast Florida MLS. Listing information is provided through a broker-sponsored Virtual Office Website for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be redistributed. A free account and terms acceptance are required to view listing details.
Listing data on this site is provided by realMLS (Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service) (Duval, St. Johns, Clay, Nassau). Listings from other multiple listing services are not shown.